June 18th, 2008

Wacom Cintiq Review

by Sergio Ordonez at 7:26 am on Resources

After long time of hesitation, I finally decided to buy a Wacom Cintiq!!!

For those who don’t know much about it, the Wacom Cintiq is a monitor on which you can paint directly on the screen, sensitive to 1024 pressure levels, just like Intuos tablets. It’s the dream of an illustrator, the material dreams are made of!!!


Have a look to the Wacom Cintiq in action, isn’t it wonderful?

(If you’re a beginner and you don’t really know what a pen tablet is, what it is for, or if you will find it profitable, I advise you to read the “Manual to choose your first pen tablet”)

The applicants: Wacom Cintiq 21UX and 12WX

Wacom Cintiq
The 20WSX version doesn’t seem to be available in Europe.

First, we have the Wacom Cintiq 21UX, a 21 inches monitor and 1024 pressure levels, with reclining stand and rotative axis. Its price in European shops is about 2500€ (about 4000US$) while in the shops of the United States it’s 2000US$.

The second option is the Wacom Cintiq 12wx, a pen tablet with integrated screen and 12 inches display, with 1024 pressure levels. Its price is 1153€ (about 2000US$) for Europeans, and 1000 US$ for the United States.

Now you may be wondering: Why to buy it in Europe, when you can do it at half its price in the United States? Simple: You’d lose the whole manufacturer warranty, besides of the cost of the shipping. If you’re a freelance and have an Intracomunitary NIF (a mere formalism), you can get it VAT free in Pixmania-Pro, and then you’d have it for 2068€. Moreover, you can reduce the income tax on 20%, so the total price would be around 1650€ for the 21UX and 790€ for the 12WX.

My choice: Cintiq 21UX

Wacom Cintiq 21UX
Cool picture, but forget about using it in that position, it weighs 10 kg. (22,05 pounds)

  • The Cintiq 21WX is very comfortable when it comes to draw, it’s much easier to coordinate eye and hand. Besides it’s huge, which eases the stroke.
  • The 12WX is a choice between the 21UX and traditional tablets, not very comfortable for drawing because of its small size, and quite more expensive than Intuos ones. It’s true that it’s more portable, but for that I already have my old Intuos 3, for just a bit more than 200€.

Assembling

Cintiq
My working area. Did you expect thousands of toys and comics? I’m a businessman :P

In less than 20 minutes I already had my Cintiq assembled and ready, it’s super-easy to install. I have it connected to my old monitor, so my working space is doubled. It’s like having a double-wide Windows desktop.
It’s a really good detail that the outlets are both in European and American version. Furthermore, it has adaptors for DVI-I, DVI-D and VGA connections.

Ergonomics

It was one of my main worries when I was going to buy it… Where will I place this doohickey? There must be a place on your desk for the mouse (in my case my Wacom Intuos 3) and the keyboard, in addition to my old monitor (a 24 inches CRT).

Wacom Cintiq at work
Up: Working position, down: Navigation position.

So I have two positions: working, with the tablet in front of me and mouse and keyboard on both sides, and navigation, with the keyboard in front of me and the mouse on one side.
Surprisingly everything matches without any problem: Thanks to the Express Keys (programmable lateral keys), the need of using the keyboard is lesser, which makes the work more comfortable.

Cintiq 21UX

The Wacom Cintiq is assembled on a reclining and rotative stand, which it’s great when it comes to draw. You can rotate the monitor, just like it was a piece of paper, and to incline it, like it was a drawing table.

The Cintiq display surface is excellent, it has a very natural touch when it comes to draw, which is something to be grateful for.

Efficiency

Generally, the Wacom Cintiq allows more precise works than pen tablets; the eye-hand coordination and the fact that you can rotate the screen let your hand make more natural movements. The number of times I use CTRL+Z has been decreased in 30-50%.

For jobs like painting it’s not very different from mi Wacom Intuos, though the efficiency is better. For drawing jobs, the efficiency is much higher. The more precise the job is, more different I find it from traditional pen tablets.

Screen

It doesn’t match the consistency of the old CRT monitors, but to my surprise the image quality is quite good. I calibrated it in just a few minutes, the colours are quite good and it offers a generous angle of sight. It has a resolution of 1600 x 1200 pixels, which is more than enough.

To cut a long story short, it’s a decent TFT active matrix LCD, and remember that you can use it together with your CRT monitor, this way any colour problem is solved.

Disadvantages

  • The screen you lean on releases heat, if you live in a warm place, you already have your sauna at home for this summer.
  • Due to the heat and the friction, sensitive hands may suffer a bit. Then you’ll have to buy a SmudgeGuard.
  • Because of its big size, you have to be athletic to reach the corners without getting tired, specially if you’re used to small tablets.
  • When you work with the stand in horizontal position, the Light from the ceiling reflects on the screen, even though the Cintiq mat surface is quite good. So, you have to choose between working in the dark or putting the lights on the floor.
  • On its horizontal position the Cintiq is about 10 cm (3,94 inches) above the desk, so you may need a higher seat.
  • While navigating through the pallets on the left in Photoshop, I usually touch the Touch Strip (zoom) by accident, which is quite bothering, although left-handed people will find it good. This problem can be solved by deactivating the Express Keys.
  • There’s a small distance between the screen and the monitor surface, at first it can be bothering but it’s not a big problem. Besides, in the software there’s an application to calibrate that difference.
  • It’s a bit heavy (10,2kg), so you can’t use it out of your desk (in opposition to 12WX model).

CONCLUSION

It’s still too soon to make a conclusion, but I have to say I’m very happy with my Cintiq. If you can afford it, the Wacom Cintiq is a wonderful device, it’s beautiful, efficient, well designed, and the most important thing: It will increase your productivity and comfort when it comes to work. You will probably need some time of accommodation, specially if you have been working with traditional tablets for a long lime, like me.

Thanks a lot to Anita for translating this article from spanish to english, please give her some love for spending some of her time with no other intention than help you :)

Related Post:

  1. Manual to choose your first graphics tablet
  2. New Youtube Channel for SOSNewbie
  3. Free mascot design (new mascot added)

13 comments »

  1. Thank you very much (and thanks to Anita for the translation), for this very informative article.

    I’ve been wondering about the Cintiq for years now, because I think it’s an awful lot of money, for something that isn’t very different (when reading about it), compared to my regular old Intous 2, which has followed me like a dear friend for the past 5 years.

    The greatest difference for me - I think - would be, that I could turn the tablet while drawing. That’s quite annoying with the Intous.. some strange position your arms end in at times ;-)

    But! I still wonder: Why do you think theres a better eye/hand coordination?

    I love my Intous, and more than that, I love the fact, that my hands aren’t in the way, when I’m drawing, opposite to drawing on paper with a pencil (I realise, that the smudgeproblem is non-existing with the Cintiq). My hands cover a freaking lot of my motive, and when you’re so used to not having hands all over, that’s just really bothering me :-)

    Next on, I would love to wait for them to take the next step, and make it alle transportable, like at laptop, with the software inside, and a battery, so I can take the baby under my arm, and go sit at the beach, while drawing. I find it kind of a downside, that I still am tied to a computer (laptop or stationairy). It would be so much more fun, if that wasn’t the case. I would like to take it to bed with me, or sit on the sofa, sketching away, while I’m watching tv with the other eye ;-)

    I know I’m asking a lot, but there can’t be such a big step between the current Cintiq, and my ultimate dream? I mean, I already have a tablet-laptop, but the surface sucks, when it comes to drawing, and if I’m folding it together, my keyboard goes away, and if I’m not folding it, my keyboard is in the way. It’s just not very good.

    Next generation Cintiq would (in my fantasyworld) include batteries, a keyboard (might be attached while transporting - keyboards are very flat these days), and software (with the choice of going with Apple og Microsoft - or whatever you want). Actually, you would have a great laptop - just with focus on the artistic needs, not for gaming or whatever people are using them for). The size could be between the two sizes you mention here (I don’t understand why it weighs so much?)

    “There’s a small distance between the screen and the monitor surface, at first it can be bothering but it’s not a big problem. Besides, in the software there’s an application to calibrate that difference.”

    Do I understand this correct? When you touch the screen with the pen, there is a little.. ehm.. time (I don’t know what to call it), before the reaction comes, and the stroke appears? That’s my main concern, due to the fact, that it is a huge problem with my current laptop (tablet edition).

    Sorry for all the babling :-)
    I really loved, that you took the time to put this together. Always really nice to read about a product from the custumers point of view.

    I would love to hear your opinion, when some time has gone by, whether you’re still happy with it - especially the pricematter/feeling/use contra the old Intous3, you already had.

    I just think it’s such a big decision, when the money is tight :-D

    Comments de Anita — June 18, 2008 @ 9:38 am

  2. Hello Anita, anything is as intuitive and accurate as drawing on paper (see the tests below).

    Dont worry for the delay beetwen the movement and the stroke appearing, its really really short, not a big deal.
    Actually your ultimate dream is real :)
    I saw a laptop with wacom cintiq screen incorporated, though I think the sensitivity was 512 levels. I was looking for the page where I saw it, but I dont find it.

    If its a issue of money, surelly I would save my money and keep my Intuos 3. With the Cintiq you will do things faster and easier, and why not, its great having that nice hardware on your desktop, but you wont do anything you cant do with your Intuos.

    I hope it helps :)
    Cheers.

    ————– TEST——————

    The Cintiq let you doing more accurate paths, take a look to this test:

    http://www.sosnewbie.com/imagenes/wacom-cintiq/cintiq-test.jpg

    A.- The active area is really big, it let you trace paths moving your pencil from the shoulder, instead the hand. When you move just the hand is almost impossible drawing a straight line (see test number 1)

    I guess with a Wacom tablet so big as the Cintiq it should be minimized.

    B.- You can rotate and turn the canvas, impossible to do with a Intuos.

    C.- You have direct input, with the Cintiq you see point A and move your hand to point B. The feedback works in real time. With the tablet you have reference of point A (the photoshop pointer) but you “imagine” where is point B.

    Do this: draw point A and point B, and now draw a line to join both points. Now rotate your tablet a few degrees… You will need several tries before you do the task properly. See how you need to imagine where is point B?

    Take a look to the image test 2, notice how I need to decrease the speed of the path to gain accuracy. When I have to do a curve instead a straight line the problem is even bigger (test 3)

    Another proof of the effect of direct feedback (test 4). I joined several points with just a line, with the Cintiq its almost perfect with the Intuos see how I go from point A to B, then I have problems to stop the pencil in the exact point(a bit too late every time).

    Comments de Sergio Ordonez — June 18, 2008 @ 11:32 pm

  3. Sorry Anita, maybe my translation isn´t as accurate as it should be at that part. I think Sergio meant that there´s a “gap” between the screen and the surface, a little space between them ;-) Not time.

    Thanks for visiting. Greetings from Spain!

    Comments de anita_nagu — June 19, 2008 @ 8:24 am

  4. Hi Anita - I think I know what you mean, I just couldn’t find the right word for it. But I think we talk about the reactiongap, from the time you hit the screen, to the time you hit the surface underneeth, that is actually creating the stroke. Right?

    I’m very lost, when it comes to explaining such an abstract thing :-D

    Comments de Anita — June 19, 2008 @ 9:04 am

  5. Hello buddies, Anita_nagu is right

    In the article I was talking about the distance from the pencil to the display, since you have a solid surface between them. So depending your point of view the cursor can look missaligned with the pencil, its because there is a utility, to calibrate this gap.

    Regarding the delay of the stroke, it will depends more on your CPU than the Wacom itself. That delay is almost null, you have to put lot of attention to realize there is a small delay… even you dont notice it.

    Comments de Sergio Ordonez — June 19, 2008 @ 10:02 am

  6. We’re talking about the same thing, I just can’t express what I mean - good thing you can :-)

    Did the lenghty comment not go through?

    Comments de Anita — June 19, 2008 @ 10:35 am

  7. Hello Anita, here is the Mod Book, its a Macbook with a wacom incorporated:

    http://axiotron.com/index.php?id=modbook

    Enjoy your dream :)

    Comments de Sergio Ordonez — July 3, 2008 @ 11:45 pm

  8. Wow - that looks amazing.

    Thank you for the link :-)

    Comments de Anita — July 14, 2008 @ 12:32 pm

  9. thats really cool. really expensive but really nice:)hope il have one in the future

    Comments de NaldzGraphics — July 28, 2008 @ 10:34 am

  10. […] this step, I try to fix the stuff I commented on from Day 2, I use my Wacom Cintiq and Photoshop, from this point everything I do is digital. I use old sketches, references from […]

    Pingback de Mascot Design In Real Time Order - the SOSFactory Way - PSDTUTS — September 15, 2008 @ 10:23 am

  11. […] this step, I try to fix the stuff I commented on from Day 2, I use my Wacom Cintiq and Photoshop, from this point everything I do is digital. I use old sketches, references from […]

    Pingback de Mascot Design In Real Time Order - the SOSFactory Way | The Human Network (HCI IDC Alumni Blog) — September 15, 2008 @ 2:30 pm

  12. […] this step, I try to fix the stuff I commented on from Day 2, I use my Wacom Cintiq and Photoshop, from this point everything I do is digital. I use old sketches, references from […]

    Pingback de PhotoShop » Blog Archive » Mascot Design In Real Time Order - the SOSFactory Way — September 15, 2008 @ 7:52 pm

  13. […] this step, I try to fix the stuff I commented on from Day 2, I use my Wacom Cintiq and Photoshop, from this point everything I do is digital. I use old sketches, references from […]

    Pingback de Design Feeds - Mascot Design In Real Time Order - the SOSFactory Way — September 20, 2008 @ 10:42 pm

RSS Comment sindication. TrackBack URI

Submit a comment

XHTML allowed tags:<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>